The Hope for a Two Nation Theory Versus the Dream of a Single Palestine Nation Without Israel

The Palestine statehood bid portrays the picture of an ill treated Palestine  seeking justice to the world. Here are the facts to note. Palestine has  consistently refused to build its state in the past; they refused the offer in  1937 from the British government, which then ruled Palestine, to divide the land  into Jewish and Arab states. Arab leaders refused again in 1947, choosing to go  to war rather than accepting the UN’s decision to partition Palestine between  Jewish and Arab populations. In 1967, Israel offered to relinquish the land it  had acquired in exchange for peace with its neighbors. The Arab world issued a  response at a summit in Khartoum, “No peace with Israel, no negotiations with  Israel, no recognition of Israel.” In 2000, under the mideast quartet proposal,  Israel’s Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered the Palestinians a sovereign state  with shared control of Jerusalem and billions of dollars in compensation for  Palestinian refugees. Yasser Arafat refused the offer, and returned to launch  the deadly terror war known as the Second Intifada.

After all the persistent refusals, Abbas beseech in pain to the world to end  the so-called historical injustice with a demand for full membership of the  state of Palestine in the UN and declared the legitimate right of Palestine to  attain its liberty and independence.

Consider the following points: statehood and settlement is not the issue for  Palestine leadership. Had it been so, Palestine leadership would have accepted  the statehood offer and built a state. If Abbas really wanted a state of  Palestine to live in peace alongside Israel, he could have given his commitment  at New York to end the conflict and extended an assurance to take action to stop  hatred and murders of Jewish people. This would have ensured the first step to  building peace and tying the knot for a bilateral agreement instead of running  to the UN.

Rejection of statehood offer clearly indicates that Palestine is not looking  for peace. The existence of Israel is the problem which is believed to be  resolved by way of internationalizing the conflict with Israel. The goal of  Palestine is a single nation to be achieved through elimination of Israel from  the map of Middle East. Palestine leadership found the viable route through a UN  bid and in attaining UN membership to use the platform and network for  challenging Israel present holdings and minimizing its territories; while at the  same time planning for an integrated action to annihilate Israel through the  Arab network. Iran’s nuclear program is part of the Israel annihilation plan.  The poster/website and Facebook campaigns are deployed to garner global sympathy  under the lies.

The horrendous remarks conferred upon Jews are enough to cause World War III.  Israel is called shamelessly an imperialist and colonialist in its homeland  conflict. Israel and Palestine do not have a relationship of a ruler and ruled  or oppressor and oppressed to disdainfully describe Israel as a fascist. The  Jews across the globe represent various racial ethnicity in different shades  that cannot justify the racist and apartheid abuses hurled at Israel. The mind  boggling allegation as children murderer in poster campaigns on internet and  face book with no evidence spits on their faces. They are ridiculed as people  with mythical origin ‘Chosen by God’. Chinese are the centre of the universe,  Muslims receive heavenly reward by demolition of non Muslims on earth, Hindu  caste system ordained an eternal status to a man through all generations and  white men racial superiority lynched the world. These absurdities of mankind are  not jeered at while it deeply hurt the world on Jewish notion of being ‘Chosen  by God’ and for being deeply attached to their ancient homeland.

Jews are treated as criminals and sinners in their self defence and accused  as trespassers in their settlement in own homeland against Arab settlers who  came as vagabonds from Egypt and Jordon in that empty land after Jews diaspora  in the aftermath of Roman invasion. The Arabs did not create any state in that  ancient Jewish homeland within this space of time. The return to their homeland  under a special humanitarian package of global sympathy is questioned by the  perverts after 65 years of its statehood and some obnoxious academicians even  dared to question the origin of a 5000 year old culture to ridicule its history  as mere myths discrediting the value of ancient scripts as literary sources for  construction of history and snobbishly  disregarding the archeological monuments  and remains of their ancestry. Life is about accommodating needs as also  empathizing suffering and it is called inclusive approach in modern day public  affairs management. The scores of unkind Arab nations on rich oil lands do not  believe in such principled approach of being inclusive and humane to make life  worthwhile and instead they waste themselves to network for a plan to oust  Israel forever.

In this notorious mission of elimination game, the pseudo intellectuals and  perverts of the world helped further to build vague theories to question Israel  history, culture and heritage in order to oppose Zionism, which their dimmed  eyes see as a cause of the problem when this is an effect of the problem of  Israel insecurity, which will disappear when the cause of the problem is  removed. By hitting the symptoms, they fuel more radical actions that fueled  more hatred towards Jews and it is not helping to solve the problem. The  propaganda against Israel as a terrorist state in their self defence is a mean  description that does not justify practical situation in life. If one’s own  existence is under threat, would anybody sit quietly? No. Agreed that Israel  retaliated to these challenges vehemently that prompted the so called  humanitarians and sympathizers to questioned on Palestinians’ civil liberties  and rights without recognizing the same occurrences in all terror situations.  The dilemma of countering terrorism and becoming a terror to the innocents is  not exclusive to one single case; it has become a global problem. Palestine  infringement on Israel civil liberties and rights are justified, but the reverse  is unjustified.

The popular poster released on websites and Facebook depicting a young kid  holding the banner ”Stop Killing Palestinian Children” in a poster campaign  blatantly alleged Israel as murderer of children without evidence. It is not to  justify killing but to see killing in the perspective of conflict situations all  over the world, global cases need to be referred to in order to validate the act  of self defence to a threat. Israel – Palestine situation is not like the  massacre of innocent civilians of middle-east dictatorship. Anti Jews campaigns  blamed the Zionist for a radical turn of events without understanding the chain  between radical action leading to another radical action and overlooking the  role of PLA that started terrorism after repeated refusal of the offer of  Palestine statehood.

In this half a century conflict. where Jewish and Palestine have been at war  openly and declared as enemies, does anybody think that killing will not occur  in such a conflict situation?. In all conflict situations, killing is the  strategy and killing will take place. In order to stop the killing,  reconciliation is proposed. The process has not been successful in  Israel-Palestine because Palestine leadership is not interested in a two nation  theory and he does not want peace. The Palestine leadership wants a single state  for Palestine through elimination of Jews.

The penetrating eye should be able to see Palestine statehood bid at the UN  and seeking UN membership today as a strategy for attaining the objective of a  single Arabic state through a methodology of annihilation of Israel and  territorial acquisition. Prejudiced campaigns alleged Israel as terrorist and a  killer while endorsing the real terrorism and supporting unsparingly their  global marketing advertisement spree to gain world sympathy for a help to attain  its birthright; yes a liberty for an ideology to operate without inhibition to  eliminate Israel from the map of the world and to eliminate the useless  supporters in due course.

Do you have hope for peace? Then stand together to urge for a bilateral  framework based on mutual respect, cooperation and coexistence for Israel and  Palestine with special commitment from Abbas to declare recognition of Israel  statehood alongside Palestine statehood.

Ms Margaret Gangte served in Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of  Finance from 1996-2006. The formulation and implementation of ‘Citizen’s  Charter’ for Public Sector Banks in 1997-98 was a landmark contribution in her  career. She received ‘Letter of Appreciation’ in 1998 from the Cabinet  Secretariat in 1998 for improving grievance redress mechanism in Public Sector  Banks. Her contribution towards improving project performance under Japanese  funding in India during 2000-2001 was recorded by the Government of Japan as the  highest disbursed Japanese ODA in South East Asia for that year and the highest  disbursed Japanese ODA for India. Her long years of experience in  bilateral/multilateral project and policy under funding from Japan, Australia  and World Bank provided a background of understanding project management and  public policy. She was one of the key contributors in restructuring Development  Financial Institutions in India during 2004-2005. The revived financial  institutions became robust and formed the backbone of India’s economic growth  today.

Ms. Margaret Gangte is an author of Journal articles.

( / 06.10.2011)

Geef een antwoord

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *